Regarding legal fees and the League's added $6 million. 

December 1, 2015

Dear Mr. Roth,
 
We believe that on previous occasions we had answered all the issues you raise in your E-mail. Nonetheless, as there seems to be some confusion, we will respond once again.
 
1.  ASL Unite and ASL 2025 are two separate entities set up by two different sets of people. ASL Unite was set up by a diverse group of people who opposed the Cantilever transaction for dissimilar reasons, including safety issues, inadequate compensation, lack of information and flat out opposition to the cantilever.

ASL 2025's mission has nothing to do with the Cantilever transaction.  It seeks to elect a Board that is transparent, accountable to membership, accessible, and values membership input. While we question the relevance of any financial disclosure by ASL 2025, we will respond to your inquiry. ASL 2025 funding comes from League members' donations -- less than $7,000 to date. The work has been performed by volunteers, some of whom also have donated materials for free.
 
As to the lawsuit, the bulk of all the legal work, including the initial litigation, has been done on a pro bono basis -- for free. The legal expenses were less than $6,000 in total and came from League member contributions. 

Mr. Barbieri originally executed a contract to sell the development rights for $25.8 in October 2013. As the court record confirms, it was only due to efforts by the League members who raised the due diligence issues - including Mr. Caraballo -- that the League gained an additional $6 million from the transaction

The appeal was taken due to the adverse effect that the trial court's ruling is likely to have the next time a real estate developer makes an offer to the Board to buy the League's 57th Street property.  The Membership's authority in such a major decision and its rights to be fully and truthfully apprised by the Board must be protected

2.  The general rule regarding pro bono work is that if an attorney believes a case is meritorious and takes it on without cost to a client, that case is considered to fall within the definition of pro bono work. This case will have broader public impact because it will define the restrictions on not-for-profit Boards in interpreting their own By-laws.
 
3.  The work of ASL 2025 is the work of a broadly supported, dedicated group of volunteers who believe that the League is headed in the wrong direction. We aren't the ones who propose reducing the Membership's voting power by 75% and giving virtually unsupervised authority over the League to one individual. 

The current Board is not transparent, accountable or responsive to the membership. ASL 2025 is the group that stands for protecting the Membership's rights, open books, as well as early and often membership involvement in League governance and all major decisions. 

Sincerely,

ASL 2025 - The Reform Team

Marne Rizika, President
Susan Brauser, Vice President
Richard Caraballo, Vice President
Roberto Franzone, Board Member
Salvatore Forte, Board Member








ASL 2025 - September 2016 Update (9/30/16)

The Great AukWord Gazette by Paul Perlow. (5/2/16)

ASL 2025 - March 2016 Update (3/17/16)

ASL 2025 Looks Forward to Seeing You in 2016! (12/10/15)

Jessica Lane: Endowment funds and building renovations. (12/2/15)

Response to Mr. Barbieri's November 30 E-mail (12/2/15)

Are you the same Mr. Cenedella? (12/2/15)

A Painting of the League, Part 3: Power and Constitution (12/2/15)

A Painting of the League, Part 2: Our Vote and Our Bloat (12/1/15)

Regarding legal fees and the League's added $6 million. (12/1/15)

A Cheerful and Lively Little Oasis for Artists (12/1/15)

A Message from Marne Rizika (12/1/15)

Mr. Torak and anonymous "instructors and friends" of ASL (12/1/15)

By-law 28: Regarding electioneering by ANY League employee (11/29/15)

Regarding The Art Students League's Original Mission (11/29/15)

My Experience at the Art Students League (11/29/15)

ASL Life Member Arthur Robbins: "The honorable thing to do" (11/29/15)

ASL Life Member Paul Perlow: "What the Golden Owl Says" (11/29/15)

Response to Brian Tepper (11/28/15)

A Painting of the League, Part 1: Introduction and Finances (11/25/15)

ASL Life Member Rick Michalek responds to Tom Torak (11/25/15)

Six answers to Mr. Tepper's questions (11/24/15)

ASL Member Marilyn Rogers: Questions to ask before you vote (11/24/15)

What John Varriano Didn't Tell You In His E-mail (11/23/15)

ASL 2025 Responds to Mr. Barbieri's E-mail of November 16 (11/23/15)

ASL 2025 Responds to Mr. Barbieri's November 19 E-mail (11/23/15)

Wallane Steele: "Why I'm running." (11/19/15)

Peter Homitzky: "What Happened to My League?" (11/17/15)

ASL Member Jose Morales Responds to Dan Gheno (11/16/15)

An Open Letter to Tom Torak (11/16/15)

Is the League College-Bound? (11/11/15)

ASL 2025 Responds to Ira Goldberg (11/9/15)

ASL 2025 Responds to Susan Matz (11/8/15)

An Open Letter to Sharon Sprung (11/6/15)

An Open Letter to Board Member Richard Baker (11/4/15)

ASL 2025 Responds to Dan Gheno (11/3/15)




Transparency
Governance